Abuse and Neglect – or do we love animals more?

When I got home from work tonight I checked the BBC News website as I’m prone to do. One of the tragic headlines that caught my eye was about two MET Police Dogs suffocating in an unventilated vehicle. This report describes an avoidable situation, whether a simple accident or careless neglect, it is a really sad story and one that I couldn’t read without feeling angry and sad for both the animals and the people involved. I believe this story went live on the BBC Website at 7pm today (27 June 2011), by the time of writing (11pm) the article has been shared over 2000 times. Quite rightly too, it is sad and newsworthy, and preventable, so sharing the message makes sense.


Now, let me rewind to four weeks ago when a BBC Panorama reported on serious institutional abuse against people with learning disabilities in Winterbourne View – I blogged about it here. This hour long documentary reported on hideous treatment of some of the most vulnerable members of our society. I think you’d struggle to watch it, or read the news item describing it, and not feel incredibly angry or sad.

This story went live on the BBC Website mid morning on the 1 June 2011, by the time of writing (27 June) the article has been shared almost 14,000 times. Again I’d expect as much, it is *also* sad and newsworthy, and *also* preventable, so sharing the message makes sense.

So, what’s the point?

I’m sure most of you will have worked out where I’m going with this. The story about animal cruelty was shared 2153 times in 3.5 hours, the adult abuse story was shared seven times as much – but in four weeks. Now I appreciate that the rate of sharing will drop off sharply once the story is removed from the BBC front page, over time, and I’m not claiming this is some scientific observation. That said, I am shocked at the high levels of concern for animal cruelty when viewed in relation to abuse of our fellow humans.

I dug a little deeper with this and checked out the statistics for the RSPCA Cruelty Line. “On average every 30 seconds someone in England and Wales dials 0300 1234 999 – the RSPCA’s 24-hour cruelty line – for help. We received more than 1.1 million phone calls during 2010″. RSPCA Key Information

The next place I looked was for an equivalent adult abuse line – but no such thing exists. Action on Elder Abuse run a free national helpline for those concerned about abuse of elderly people, but that does not speak to all adult groups. I was unable to find any figures about it’s use.

So desperate to explore my theory that we care more about animals than people, I checked up on stats from NSPCC, I couldn’t find 2010 figures but what follows is the stats about calls made by children to ChildLine (which covers any concerns they have, including abuse) and calls from adults to the Helpline in 2009-10: “ChildLine counsellors dealt with over 500,000 contacts from children calling about various problems including bullying, sex abuse, violence and mental health issues. Nearly 12,000 allegations of children suffering abuse were passed from the NSPCC Helpline to police of social services” NSPCC Facts and figures about child abuse.

I’d like to conclude by offering the suggestion that we really do love our animals more than our fellow people.

I’m not sure if I believe that, but I think it’s relatively easy to see that we appear to be more appalled by animal cruelty and if not more appalled, more likely to act about it. Whether it’s a self-protection, not wanting to consider the reality situation; or a lack of awareness; or a lack of knowledge about what to do about it, I’m not sure. What I am sure about is that no animal or person should be subjected to abuse or neglect and as a society we should be more appalled and more proactive in preventing it.


RSPCA Cruelty Line 0300 1234 999

NSPCC HelpLine 0800 800 5000 and ChildLine 0800 1111

Action on Elder Abuse Helpline 0808 808 8141

If you are concerned about a vulnerable person (adult or child) suffering abuse and don’t know what to do about it contact 999 if it is an emergency or a crime or contact your local council or police force for other concerns. Usually if you Google ‘reporting adult abuse’ and ‘the area where you live’ you will usually find what to do.

4 thoughts on “Abuse and Neglect – or do we love animals more?

  1. You raise an interesting point and I’d never defend any form of abuse.
    Two points I will make though.
    Ignoring the police dog case because it was not (I hope) a case of malicious abuse. There is a very strong link between people who abuse animals and then go on to abuse, attack and even kill humans. So I think that identifying animal abusers serves to do more than just protect the animals.
    My second point is that I’d say if there were over a million calls to the RSPCA that we don’t love our animals that much, else why the high number of abuse cases.

  2. Here’s my again very unscientific theory. People ‘care’ more about children and animals because they engender pity and sympathy – abuse is caused by ‘other’ people and it won’t affect us directly.
    Adult abuse, particularly older adults is something that could happen in our future and we are more inclined to want to ‘forget’ that it happens.

  3. George again another great thought provoking post here are my two penneth worth.

    1. With our three animals (2 dogs and a cat) we have agreed that there is a price limit on their conditions. Not because I am heartless but rather that I cannot justify huge vets bills for say investigative operations and the like whilst there are many organisations trying to do so much work for children around the world. Hence my hierarchy of value does link to children first having a full and potential.

    2. Linked to the point about children is the amount the charity sector raises on behalf of animals welfare. I was astounded at the level of income for the cats protection league when we visited them last year. Their income statement showed a huge amount from legacies – “hey I’ll leave it all the the cats home” type of thing.

    In summ Animals and children seem to win every time?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s